One hundred fifty years
after Russian chemist Dmitri Mendeleev published his system for neatly
arranging the elements, the periodic table it gave birth to hangs in every
chemistry classroom in the world and is one of the field’s most recognizable
symbols. But the solid squares and familiar patterns of today’s table mask one
of its fundamental characteristics: “the” periodic table does not exist.
It’s been mutable from the beginning. Not only has it grown as
new elements have been discovered; it has also added columns and changed shape
as we’ve gained new understanding of the elements’ properties and their
relationships to one another. And scientists are still debating its optimum
configuration.
Some believe chemical
properties should dictate how the elements line up on the periodic table.
Others think a more fundamental principle is needed, like electronic
configuration or simply atomic number. Partisans are clashing over which
elements belong in group 3, where helium should go, and how many columns the
periodic table should have. They follow a long line of chemists and physicists
who have worked and reworked the elements into a semblance of order.
“What I find interesting
about the current debate is there are people who insist on there being one
right table,” says Michael D. Gordin, a Princeton University historian who has
written about Mendeleev, Julius Lothar Meyer, and other creators of early
periodic tables. “It would have struck people like Mendeleev and Lothar Meyer
as weird.” Gordin says the periodic table pioneers understood their tables to
be a reflection of natural laws but recognized that different tables could
represent those laws in different ways. That might be hard to imagine for those
of us used to seeing the familiar shape of the table on our coffee mug or
shower curtain.
Setting
the table
Mendeleev wasn’t the
first to recognize patterns in the elements, nor was he the first to try to
depict those patterns in a diagram. Chemist Johann Wolfgang Döbereiner, for
instance, identified triads of elements with shared properties in 1829. Today
we’d recognize these as members of the same group or column of the periodic
table, like chlorine, bromine, and iodine.
Geologist Alexandre-Émile
Béguyer de Chancourtois published a kind of periodic table in 1862 in which the
elements spiraled up a cylinder according to atomic weight. Each column of
elements shared properties.
Get Free Quote!
405 Experts Online